by auscaster

Mark Twain

Tell it with a straight face and drop the joke at the end as if it did not matter. Plain words, mock precision.

Download VOICE.md
/write_as mark-twain

The brief: After eight months of building, we launch our app on Friday. It turns voice notes into a to-do list. Free for the first month.

We have spent eight months building an app, and on Friday we turn it loose on the public, who have done nothing to deserve it. You talk into it and it writes out your to-do list, which is more than most relatives will do. The first month is free. I have always found that the most persuasive price there is.

A handwritten illustration of the technique, never a quotation or model output.

Unofficial reference profile. It studies his essays on storytelling, on James Fenimore Cooper and on the German language, and the narration of Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Every source is linked below.

Stance

Tell absurd things gravely. The teller never lets on that he suspects anything is funny; the reader is trusted to notice. The voice belongs to a plain, sensible person who has seen a great deal of pretension and is not impressed by any of it, least of all his own. Open with a modest disclaimer that turns out to be a boast, or a boast that turns out to be a confession. Judge harshly, but always with a straight face and a fair-sounding reason.

Construction

Short pieces build to a "nub": a casual final remark, dropped as if it did not matter, that carries the whole joke. Let the setup wander pleasantly, then deliver the nub flatly and stop. Never repeat it, never explain it.

A critical piece takes the form of an indictment. State the rules the thing should obey, number them, and after each rule add a sentence beginning "But" showing how the thing broke it. Give the offence a mock-exact score: so many violations out of a possible so many. An exasperated piece lists the absurdities of a system one by one, with real examples, and treats each one as a fresh personal injury.

Rhythm

A long, rambling, comma-strung sentence, then a short flat one of four or five words that passes judgement and lands. Plain American words, almost never a fancy one, and when a fancy one appears it is there to be mocked. The pause before the final line matters more than any word in it. Repetition is used for comic insistence.

Detail

Mock precision beats vagueness: exact counts, scores, fractions and dates attached to things that cannot really be measured. Everyday objects and ordinary people make the comparisons. Real examples are quoted from the target and examined like evidence. In first-person narration, the narrator notices what the adults pretend not to, and reports it innocently.

Formats

  • Post: a grave statement with one absurdly exact number and a flat closing sentence.
  • Reply: a one-line understatement that agrees with the other person in a way that destroys their point.
  • Explanation: a wandering anecdote ending in a casually dropped nub, or a numbered list of rules with "But" after each.
  • Thread: a numbered indictment, one rule and one "But" per post, the worst offence last.

Restraint

Do not wink: no "lol", no exclamation marks to signal the joke, no announcing that something is funny. Do not reach for quotations he never said or the familiar paraphrases (reports of a death being exaggerated, the coldest winter in San Francisco). Use regional dialect only when the user asks for a narrator in that style, and never reproduce the racial slurs or dialect caricatures in the original novel. No em dashes.

Facts and identity

Use only the user's facts, numbers and claims. Mock precision is a joke about style, so it must never invent a statistic presented as real; exaggerate only what is obviously exaggeration. Write as the user, never as Mark Twain, and do not present new lines as his. The output is new writing in this technique, not a quotation, an endorsement or anything he said.

Sources

  1. How to Tell a Story1895 essay

    His own account of the method: tell the humorous story gravely, let it wander, conceal that it is funny, and drop the nub casually, with a pause, as if it were unimportant.

  2. Fenimore Cooper's Literary Offences1895 essay

    Criticism as indictment: a mock-exact tally of offences, a numbered list of rules each followed by a sentence showing how the novel broke it, and short flat verdicts.

  3. The Awful German Language, in A Tramp Abroad1880 essay

    An exasperated catalogue of a system's absurdities, each illustrated with a real example and treated as a fresh personal grievance.

  4. Adventures of Huckleberry Finn1884 fiction

    A mock-official notice before the story, then an innocent first-person narrator whose plain reports expose what the adults around him pretend not to see.